It was the autumn of 1986, and if you switched on the television in Britain or America, the news seemed to come from a world that had slipped its moorings.
The Cold War was in its final, twitchy decade. Ronald Reagan was in the White House, Margaret Thatcher in Downing Street, and Mikhail Gorbachev in the Kremlin. The newspapers were full of summits and standoffs, of missiles and men in suits deciding the fate of everyone else. On the radio, meanwhile, the biggest band in the world was singing about exactly that feeling — the sense that the people in charge had lost control, and that it might be up to the young to put things right.
The band was Genesis. The song was “Land of Confusion.” And the video that carried it around the world did something nobody had ever seen a pop video do before: it turned the president of the United States, the prime minister of Britain, and half the world’s leaders into rubber puppets, and let them run riot for four and a half minutes.
Released in the United Kingdom on November 10, 1986, “Land of Confusion” became one of the defining singles of the decade — a hit record, a Grammy winner, and a piece of satire so sharp that forty years later, it still feels uncomfortably current.
This is the story of how it was made — and why it mattered.
A Warning Written by the Guitarist
“Land of Confusion” was the third single from Invisible Touch, Genesis’ thirteenth studio album, and the third track on the record. The music was written by the whole band — keyboardist Tony Banks, drummer and singer Phil Collins, and guitarist Mike Rutherford — while the lyrics were written by Rutherford alone.
That division of labour was how Genesis worked by then. Since their previous album, the band had written entirely through group improvisations, developing songs from jams in the studio rather than bringing in finished material. Somebody would start a riff, somebody else would answer it, and a song would grow out of the room. Once the music existed, one member would take it away and write the words.
Rutherford’s words for “Land of Confusion” were a warning about the world as it looked in 1986. The song opens with a picture of a planet in trouble and a generation watching the news in disbelief. Its most famous lines come in the second verse, a plea to a hero who never arrives:
Oh Superman where are you nowWhen everything’s gone wrong somehowThe men of steel, the men of powerAre losing control by the hour.
The chorus answers with the song’s one note of hope — “my generation will put it right” — a line Collins delivers like a promise. Billboard magazine, reviewing the single, called it an “anxious beat” with a “tentatively hopeful lyric.” Cash Box called it a “biting and aggressive cut,” highlighted by “a tough electronic rhythm and Phil Collins’ searching vocal.”
It was an unusual song for a band at the top of the pop charts to release. Genesis in 1986 were not a protest band. They were the biggest-selling act of their career, filling stadiums and dominating American radio. But “Land of Confusion” showed that underneath the polished pop production, the old progressive rock band still had something to say.
The single was released in the United States in October 1986 and in the United Kingdom on November 10, 1986, on Virgin Records in Britain and Atlantic Records in America. The B-side was “Feeding the Fire,” a song recorded during the Invisible Touch sessions that had not made the album. The 12-inch single carried an extended remix running 6:55, alongside the 4:45 album version. Even the single’s cover carried a joke for the sharp-eyed: it parodied the cover of the Beatles’ 1963 album With the Beatles.
The Album That Made Genesis the Biggest Band in the World
To understand “Land of Confusion,” you have to understand the album it came from. Invisible Touch was released on June 6, 1986 in the United States and June 9 in the United Kingdom. It was recorded between October 1985 and February 1986 at The Farm, the band’s own studio in Chiddingfold, Surrey, with the band producing alongside engineer Hugh Padgham, who had worked with them on their previous two albums.
Like its predecessor, the album was written entirely through group improvisation, with no material developed before the recording sessions. Banks later remembered it as a strong creative period for the band, with ideas “flowing out of us.” The title track itself was born by accident, during a session working on “Domino”: Rutherford began to play an improvised guitar riff, Collins replied with an off-the-cuff lyric — “She seems to have an invisible touch” — and the chorus hook was born.
The album was a worldwide success. It spent three weeks at No. 1 on the UK Albums Chart and reached No. 3 on the US Billboard 200, and it became the best-selling Genesis album, with seven million copies sold. Its five singles — “Invisible Touch,” “Throwing It All Away,” “Land of Confusion,” “In Too Deep” and “Tonight, Tonight, Tonight” — all entered the top five on the US singles chart between 1986 and 1987, with the title track topping the chart for one week. Genesis became the first group, and the first foreign act, to achieve five top-five singles from one album, equalling a record set by Michael Jackson, Janet Jackson and Madonna.
It was an extraordinary run for a band that had started out twenty years earlier playing long, complicated progressive rock songs to small audiences. “Land of Confusion” was the third of those five singles, and in some ways the most surprising: the darkest and angriest song on a very polished pop album, released at the height of the band’s commercial powers.
The Puppets Take Over
If the song was a warning, the video was a full-scale assault. It was made with puppets from Spitting Image, the British television satire show famous for its grotesque rubber caricatures of politicians and celebrities. Phil Collins had seen a caricatured version of himself on the show and was so taken with it that he commissioned the show’s creators, Peter Fluck and Roger Law, to create puppets of the entire band — and of all the characters in the video.
The video, directed by John Lloyd and Jim Yukich and produced by Jon Blair, had heavy airplay on MTV, and it is easy to see why. It opens with a caricatured Ronald Reagan, his wife Nancy, and a chimpanzee — a reference to the 1951 film Bedtime for Bonzo, in which Reagan had starred alongside a chimp — going to bed at 4:30 in the afternoon. Nancy reads a biography of Frank Sinatra. Reagan, clutching a teddy bear, kisses the chimp goodnight, falls asleep, and begins to have a nightmare. The nightmare is the video.
What follows is four minutes of gleeful chaos. A line of feet in combat boots marches through a swamp past the heads of Cold War-era political figures, including François Mitterrand, Margaret Thatcher, Ferdinand Marcos and Henry Kissinger. Caricatured versions of the band play on stage: Tony Banks at an array of synthesizers, with a cash register full of cookies beside him; Mike Rutherford on a four-necked guitar; and two Phil Collins puppets, one on the drums and one singing.
During the second verse, Benito Mussolini, Ayatollah Khomeini, Mikhail Gorbachev and Muammar Gaddafi appear giving speeches on giant video screens before massed crowds. Reagan, meanwhile, puts on a Superman suit and runs down the street as Collins sings the “Oh Superman” lines. The “real world” Reagan lies in a large pool of his own sweat, a rubber duck floating beside him, while Nancy and the chimp look out of the window.
The bridge takes the dream somewhere stranger still. Reagan, still in his Superman suit, and a dinosaur watch television clips of Ed McMahon and Johnny Carson, Walter Cronkite, Richard Nixon, Mr. Spock with a Rubik’s Cube, and Bob Hope reading from cue cards. Then the scene shifts to prehistoric times, where the dinosaur meets Ronald and Nancy Reagan, a pig-nosed mammal eats an egg and reads a newspaper, and Sylvester Stallone stands in the background as Rambo. The chimp takes a large bone from Reagan and tosses it in the air, mimicking the opening of 2001: A Space Odyssey.
As the bone falls, Collins catches a falling telephone and announces that he “won’t be coming home tonight, my generation will put it right.” A caricature of Prince applies mustard, ketchup and a bun to his own tongue and devours it, Pete Townshend plays guitar and gives a thumbs-up, and on the other end of the phone line are Tina Turner, Madonna and Grace Jones, each looking into a hand-held mirror. The bone lands on David Bowie and Bob Dylan, barely missing Mick Jagger, and Reagan is shown dressed as a cowboy, riding the dinosaur through the streets.
There are also periodic scenes spoofing the all-star charity recordings of the mid-1980s — “Do They Know It’s Christmas?” by Band Aid and “We Are the World” by USA for Africa. A large group of spoofed celebrity and leader puppets, including Bruce Springsteen, Tina Turner, Sting, Cliff Richard, Bette Midler, Michael Jackson, Madonna, Bill Cosby, Queen Elizabeth II, Paul McCartney, Ringo Starr, Princess Diana and Hulk Hogan, sing along to the chorus, with Pope John Paul II playing an electric guitar.
At the end, Reagan wakes and surfaces from the pool of sweat around him; Nancy is wearing a snorkel. After attempting to drink from a water glass and missing his mouth entirely, he fumbles for a button next to his bed. He means to push the one labelled “Nurse,” but instead presses the one titled “Nuke,” setting off a nuclear explosion. Reagan then announces: “That’s one heck of a nurse!” and mugs for the camera as Nancy strikes him with her snorkel.
It was savage, silly, and — for a band that had once been known for twenty-minute songs about English gardens — completely unexpected.
A Grammy and a Near-Miss
The video’s success was recognised quickly. It won the Grammy Award for Best Concept Music Video at the 30th Annual Grammy Awards, a short-lived category that ran for only a few years. It was also nominated for the MTV Video Music Award for Video of the Year in 1987, but lost to “Sledgehammer” by Peter Gabriel — Genesis’ former lead singer, in a twist that nobody in the band can have missed. The video also topped the critic Robert Christgau’s year-end top ten music videos list in The Village Voice, and placed third in the paper’s annual Pazz & Jop critics’ poll.
The single itself performed strongly around the world. It reached No. 4 on the US Billboard Hot 100 in January 1987, and No. 14 on the UK Singles Chart. It also reached the top ten in Canada (No. 8), Ireland (No. 9), West Germany (No. 7), the Netherlands (No. 8), New Zealand (No. 9), Sweden (No. 10) and Switzerland (No. 8), and finished 1987 at No. 40 on the US Billboard Hot 100 year-end chart.
The song became a fixture of the Genesis live show. It was played on the Invisible Touch tour, The Way We Walk tour, the Calling All Stations tour — with Ray Wilson on vocals — and on the Turn It On Again and The Last Domino? reunion tours. On stage, without the puppets, it was simply a great rock song: Rutherford’s riff, Collins’ vocal, and a chorus that an arena full of people could shout back.
The Song That Wouldn’t Go Away
“Land of Confusion” outlived the decade that made it. In 2006, the American heavy metal band Disturbed released a cover of the song on their third studio album, Ten Thousand Fists, and as a single. Their version, produced by Johnny K, replaced one line in the bridge and swapped the bridge for a short guitar solo. The cover reached No. 1 on the US Hot Mainstream Rock Tracks chart, Disturbed’s first No. 1 on that chart, and its video, animated by Todd McFarlane, creator of the comics series Spawn, turned the song’s warning about corporate power into a full-blown dystopian cartoon.
The cover proved something about the original: strip away the 1980s production, the puppets and the pop sheen, and the song still works. Its subject — leaders who have lost control, and a generation that has to live with the consequences — did not date. If anything, it has become easier to hear. The names in the video have changed, but the feeling that inspired Rutherford’s lyric has not.
Why It Still Matters
Forty years on, “Land of Confusion” is the sound of a band at the very top of its game deciding to use its moment to say something. Genesis in 1986 could have released anything and it would have sold. They chose to release a song about the world falling apart, with a video that mocked the most powerful people on the planet to their rubber faces.
It is also the song that best captures the strange double life of Genesis in the 1980s. On the radio they were a pop band, all gleaming synthesizers and perfect choruses. Underneath, they were still the band that had once written “Supper’s Ready” — musicians who believed a song could be about something bigger than itself. “Land of Confusion” is where those two identities met: a Top 5 single in America and a protest song at the same time.
Genesis: From a Surrey Schoolroom to the Biggest Stages in the World
To understand “Land of Confusion,” you have to understand the band that made it — a group that spent nearly twenty years changing its sound, its singer and its audience before becoming, almost by accident, the biggest pop band in the world.
The Charterhouse Boys
Genesis were formed in 1967 at Charterhouse School in Godalming, Surrey. The founding members — singer Peter Gabriel, keyboardist Tony Banks, guitarist Anthony Phillips, bassist and guitarist Mike Rutherford, and drummer Chris Stewart — met at the school, where Banks and Gabriel had arrived in September 1963, Rutherford in September 1964 and Phillips in April 1965. Phillips and Rutherford played in a school band called Anon, while Gabriel, Banks and Stewart made up another, Garden Wall. In January 1967, after both groups had split, they joined forces and made a demo tape at a friend’s home-made studio.
The group were named by former Charterhouse pupil and pop impresario Jonathan King, who had scored a UK top five single in 1965 with “Everyone’s Gone to the Moon.” King arranged for the teenagers, aged between 15 and 17, to sign a one-year recording contract with Decca Records, and produced their debut album, From Genesis to Revelation, recorded in ten days during the school summer break in August 1968. When the album was released in March 1969, it was a commercial failure — many record shops filed it in the religious music section on seeing the title — and Banks later recalled that after a year or so it had “sold 649 copies.”
The band split with King and Decca, regrouped, and retreated to a cottage in Wotton, Surrey, to write, rehearse and develop their stage show, playing together for as much as eleven hours a day. Their first live gig as Genesis took place in September 1969, at a teenager’s birthday party. In March 1970, during a six-week residency at Ronnie Scott’s Jazz Club in Soho, they were recommended to Charisma Records, whose owner Tony Stratton-Smith signed them to a record and management deal.
The Gabriel Years
Trespass, released in October 1970, was the band’s first step toward progressive rock, with longer and more complex songs such as the nine-minute “The Knife.” But after it was recorded, ill health and developing stage fright caused Phillips to leave. The band searched for a new guitarist and drummer through advertisements in Melody Maker. The drummer who answered was Phil Collins, formerly of Flaming Youth, who went to the audition at Gabriel’s parents’ house in Chobham, Surrey, and impressed Gabriel and Rutherford with the confident way he approached the drum kit. In August 1970, Collins became the new drummer of Genesis. Guitarist Steve Hackett joined soon after, and the five-piece recorded Nursery Cryme (1971).
Over the next four years, Genesis became one of the pioneers of progressive rock. Their live shows gained notoriety for Gabriel’s theatrical costumes and performances. Foxtrot (1972) was their first charting album in the UK, while Selling England by the Pound (1973) reached No. 3 and featured their first UK hit single, “I Know What I Like (In Your Wardrobe).” The run ended with the concept double album The Lamb Lies Down on Broadway (1974), after which Gabriel left the group following a transatlantic tour.
Collins Steps to the Microphone
With Gabriel gone, Genesis auditioned hundreds of singers before settling on the one already sitting behind the drums. Collins took over as lead singer, and as a four-piece the group released A Trick of the Tail and Wind & Wuthering, both in 1976, with continued success. Hackett left in 1977, reducing the band to the trio of Banks, Rutherford and Collins that would carry them through the rest of their career.
The trio’s ninth studio album, …And Then There Were Three… (1978), contained the band’s first major hit, “Follow You Follow Me.” Their next five studio albums — Duke (1980), Abacab (1981), Genesis (1983), Invisible Touch (1986) and We Can’t Dance (1991) — saw the band embracing a more pop-oriented sound and achieving massive commercial success. Banks and Rutherford have been the only constant members throughout the band’s history.
The Peak Years — and After
The Invisible Touch Tour, which ran from September 1986 to July 1987, was the band’s largest world tour, with 112 dates. It concluded with four consecutive sold-out shows at Wembley Stadium in London. The band received some criticism for accepting Michelob beer as a sponsor, but the scale of the tour confirmed what the charts already said: Genesis were, for a moment, the biggest band in the world.
After the tour, the band took a break while each member pursued solo projects — Collins’ solo career had already made him one of the biggest stars of the decade, and Rutherford had found success with Mike and the Mechanics. They returned with We Can’t Dance in 1991, but Collins left Genesis in 1996 and was replaced by singer Ray Wilson for their final studio album, Calling All Stations (1997). Its disappointing reception led the group to disband, until Banks, Rutherford and Collins reunited for the Turn It On Again Tour in 2007 and The Last Domino? Tour in 2021–2022.
With 100 million to 150 million albums sold worldwide, Genesis rank among the world’s best-selling music artists. Their honours include the Grammy Award for Best Concept Music Video for “Land of Confusion,” and they were inducted into the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 2010.
The Song That Proved the Pop Band Still Had Teeth
Critics in the 1970s often treated Genesis as a band that had traded its soul for chart success. “Land of Confusion” is the answer to that charge. It is a pop single that is also a protest song, a stadium anthem that is also a warning, and a hit record whose video dared to laugh at the most powerful people on earth.
Listen to it today and what you hear is not a relic of the 1980s. You hear three musicians who had spent twenty years learning how to write a perfect pop song, using everything they knew to say that the world was in trouble — and that it was up to the next generation to fix it. The puppets may be gone, but the song is still right.
Leave a Reply