Before Neil Diamond was the sequined showman of the Greek Theatre, before “Sweet Caroline” became the most joyful singalong in sports stadiums around the world, he was a pre-med student at NYU who could barely afford to eat. The road from a fencing scholarship to the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame ran through some of the strangest detours in music history — including a police helicopter, a song he gave away that became the biggest hit of 1966, and a high school choir with a girl named Barbara Streisand.
The Doctor Who Chose $50 a Week
Neil Leslie Diamond was born January 24, 1941, in Brooklyn, the son of a dry-goods store owner. He was a serious student — serious enough to win a fencing scholarship to New York University, where he enrolled as a pre-med major and even earned a spot on the 1960 NCAA championship fencing team. Medicine was the plan. Music was the distraction: he found himself so bored in lectures that he’d write song lyrics in the margins of his notebooks, then cut class to ride the train up to Tin Pan Alley, hawking his songs to publishers.
Then, in his senior year — just ten credits shy of graduation — Sunbeam Music Publishing offered him a sixteen-week job writing songs for $50 a week. He dropped out of college to take it. It was the kind of gamble that either ruins a life or makes one. For Diamond, it did both in sequence: Sunbeam didn’t renew his contract, Columbia Records signed and then dropped him, and he found himself back in the Brill Building, New York’s legendary songwriting factory, barely surviving. At one point he was living on thirty-five cents a day for food, writing in a tiny rented room above the Birdland jazz club with only a piano for company. He was stockpiling songs that would carry him for decades — he just didn’t know it yet.
The Hit He Gave Away
In 1966, Don Kirshner — the music mogul behind the Monkees — needed songs for his manufactured TV band. Diamond had a tune he’d intended to record himself. The Monkees recorded it instead, and “I’m a Believer” shot to number one, where it stayed for seven weeks, becoming the biggest-selling single of 1966. Diamond followed it with two more Monkees hits, “A Little Bit Me, A Little Bit You” and “Look Out (Here Comes Tomorrow),” plus “Sunday and Me” for Jay and the Americans.
The irony was exquisite and a little painful: the world was singing Neil Diamond’s songs, but it wasn’t Neil Diamond singing them. He had always meant to keep “I’m a Believer” for himself. Watching a faux-Beatle TV band turn his throwaway into the song of the year was the push he needed — he was done giving his best material away. Within months he was on Bang Records cutting “Solitary Man” and “Cherry, Cherry,” launching the recording career that would eventually sell more than 130 million records. But for the rest of his life, whenever “I’m a Believer” played, Diamond could hear the ghost of the career that almost wasn’t his.
The Choir Girl Named Barbara
Here’s a detail that sounds invented but isn’t: as a teenager at Brooklyn’s Erasmus Hall High School, Neil Diamond sang in the hundred-member school chorus alongside a young classmate named Barbara — not yet “Barbra” — Streisand. Two of the biggest voices of the twentieth century, teenagers in matching choir robes, singing school concerts together in Brooklyn. They would cross paths again, memorably, on the 1978 duet “You Don’t Bring Me Flowers,” which became a number one hit for both of them. But it started in a high school auditorium, two kids from Brooklyn with impossible voices and no idea what was coming.
Ten Nights That Made a Legend
Before the Aladdin, there was the Greek. In August 1972, Diamond played a ten-night stand at the Greek Theatre in Los Angeles — and recorded it. The resulting double album, “Hot August Night,” captured something no studio ever could: Diamond the showman, dripping with sweat in an open shirt, conducting ten thousand people like a revival preacher. It became one of the defining live albums of the era and turned him from a hitmaker into a phenomenon. He’d actually walked away from touring for four years before that, exhausted and wanting to be home with his family; “Hot August Night” was the sound of a man remembering, in public, why he did this at all.
The same restless ambition led him to score the 1973 film “Jonathan Livingston Seagull,” a project that baffled many fans — a concept album about a philosophical seagull — but earned him a Grammy and proved he couldn’t sit still creatively. He turned down movie roles that might have made him a different kind of star entirely, including “Lenny” and Martin Scorsese’s “Taxi Driver.” Somewhere there’s a universe where Neil Diamond growls “You talkin’ to me?” Our universe got “Song Sung Blue” instead. Probably for the best.
The Night the Cops Crashed the Party
By the summer of 1976, Diamond was at the peak of his powers. He had agreed — after turning down nearly every major hotel in Las Vegas for years — to open the brand-new, $10 million Aladdin Theatre for the Performing Arts. The payday was staggering: $650,000 for five shows, a record at the time. The hotel named a suite after him and threw the opening-night party in a banquet room coincidentally called the Diamond Room.
The night before he left for Vegas, the police came. Acting on an anonymous tip about cocaine, a joint force of sheriff’s deputies and police officers — dozens of them, with a helicopter hovering overhead — descended on Diamond’s Holmby Hills home at 10:30 p.m. An officer at the gate claimed they were checking on a possible burglar; Diamond buzzed them in, and suddenly they were presenting a search warrant. For three hours they went through all ten rooms of the house, including the bedroom where Diamond’s five-year-old son Jesse was sleeping. They found no cocaine. What they found was less than an ounce of marijuana.
There was no arrest — California had just decriminalized small amounts — but the city attorney’s office filed a misdemeanor complaint on July 2, 1976: opening night. While lawyers took center stage in Los Angeles, Diamond took the stage in Las Vegas, performing on schedule before a sold-out house that included his parents, with no idea of the drama unfolding behind the scenes. As the officers were leaving his house that night, Diamond — ever the showman — handed each of them an autographed copy of his new album, “Beautiful Noise.” You can’t make this stuff up.
The Flops, the Pot Song, and the Razzie
For all his triumphs, Diamond has a couple of skeletons in his musical closet, and he’s remarkably honest about them. In the late 1960s he got involved with Phoenix House, a New York anti-drug program, and felt compelled to write about what he was seeing. The result was “The Pot Smoker’s Song,” a semi-documentary track on his 1968 album “Velvet Gloves and Spit” featuring the actual voices of addicts telling their stories. It was, by his own later admission, terrible. “Oh, it was terrible! It was laughed at,” he told Q magazine decades later. He even winced at the album’s title. It’s a rare thing — a superstar volunteering his most embarrassing artistic moment — and it makes you like him more. The man who wrote “Sweet Caroline” also wrote a song so bad he still cringes. That’s called being human.
Then came the big-screen embarrassment. In 1980, Diamond made his acting debut in “The Jazz Singer,” a remake of the 1927 classic. Producer Jerry Leider had been inspired after seeing Diamond’s 1976 Greek Theatre television special and believed he could be the next Barbra Streisand or Elvis Presley — a singer who conquered film. Diamond wrote ten original songs for the movie, including “Love on the Rocks,” “Hello Again,” and “America,” and the soundtrack was a massive hit. The film itself was not. Critics were brutal, and Diamond earned a distinction nobody wants: the very first Razzie Award for Worst Actor. He took it in stride — the songs outlived the reviews, and “America” became an anthem in its own right. He also turned down film roles that might have made him a different kind of star entirely, including parts in “Lenny” and Martin Scorsese’s “Taxi Driver.” Imagine Neil Diamond as Travis Bickle. Some alternate universes are better left unexplored.
Caroline’s Secret
For nearly forty years, nobody knew who “Caroline” was. Diamond finally revealed in 2007 that the inspiration for “Sweet Caroline” — written in 1969 and a number four hit — was a photograph he’d seen years earlier of a young Caroline Kennedy, the president’s daughter, riding a horse. He’d been struck by her sweetness, and when he needed a name that rhymed, “Caroline” unlocked the whole song. He later sang it to Caroline Kennedy herself at her fiftieth birthday celebration. From a magazine photo of an eleven-year-old girl to the most belted-out chorus in sports history — only Neil Diamond could connect those dots.
The Last Bow
In January 2018, on the eve of his fiftieth anniversary tour, Diamond announced he had Parkinson’s disease and was retiring from touring. It was a devastating moment for millions of fans. But Diamond wasn’t finished. In December 2022, he walked onstage at Broadway’s Broadhurst Theatre during the opening of “A Beautiful Noise,” the musical about his life, and sang “Sweet Caroline” with the cast — his first major public performance in years. The theater shook. He has since made surprise appearances, including a 2025 charity gala performance, his baritone weathered but unbroken.
Neil Diamond’s story is really the story of the American song itself: the Brill Building grind, the borrowed fame, the stadium glory, the graceful fight against time. He started as a kid who gave his best songs away for $50 a week and ended as the man whose songs belong to everyone. Along the way he collected honors few artists ever touch — the Songwriters Hall of Fame, the Rock and Roll Hall of Fame, the Kennedy Center Honors, a Grammy Lifetime Achievement Award — but the real monument is simpler: a chorus the whole world knows by heart, sung at ballparks and weddings and karaoke bars by people who weren’t born when he wrote it. The pre-med student never became a doctor. Instead, he spent more than sixty years healing people a different way — three minutes at a time, one sequined show at a time, leaving behind a timeless catalog that will outlive us all.
Leave a Reply