They named themselves after a fire truck. Their first singer quit by climbing out of a moving car and vanishing into the night. Their second singer was fired mid-album, rehired years later, and then mocked by his own bandmates for writing the power ballad that made them superstars. REO Speedwagon sold forty million records on the strength of Midwestern stubbornness — and nearly tore itself apart over the very songs that made it famous.
A Truck, a Dorm Basement, and a Food Fight
In the fall of 1966, Neal Doughty was a junior at the University of Illinois in Champaign, starting an electrical engineering program. On his first night of classes, he met a fellow student named Alan Gratzer, a drummer. The two held an impromptu keyboard-and-drum jam in the basement of their dormitory, and the seeds of a band were planted.
Months later, Doughty spotted a name written on a blackboard in a History of Transportation class: the REO Speed Wagon, a flatbed truck built by the Ransom Eli Olds company back in 1915. The band adopted it — spelling out the letters, R.E.O., rather than pronouncing it “RE-oh” like the truck company did, a distinction die-hard fans still observe — and their first frat gig promptly devolved into a food fight. It was not an auspicious beginning. But the band gigged relentlessly around Illinois, playing covers of the Doors and Cream, and became the biggest bar act in Champaign — a college town that also happened to be home to Dan Fogelberg.
Then came the break: a then-unknown manager named Irving Azoff took them on. Azoff would go on to guide the Eagles and Steely Dan to multi-platinum glory, but in those days he was just a hungry kid from the Midwest who believed in a bar band named after a truck. He got them a deal with Epic Records, and their 1971 self-titled debut — full-tilt bar-room rock — arrived to little notice. It failed to chart. The band needed a singer with star power, and Azoff told his new secret weapon to go find one.
The Singer Who Vanished Into the Dark
That secret weapon was Gary Richrath, a guitarist from Peoria who had watched REO play and decided, as he later put it, “I’m going to be part of that band whether they like it or not.” He drove a hundred miles south and muscled his way into the lineup — and promptly clashed with the band’s singer, Terry Luttrell.
Luttrell’s exit became instant band legend. According to drummer Alan Gratzer, Luttrell quit by simply getting out of a car on the way back from a show and disappearing into the dark. No farewell speech, no final gig — just a man stepping out of a car and walking away from a rock band forever. (Luttrell resurfaced years later fronting the prog-rockers Starcastle, but in REO lore he remains the singer who dissolved into the night.)
Richrath, tasked with finding a replacement, noticed homemade flyers around Chicago music stores advertising a “Musician Referral Service.” One flyer featured a rhythm guitarist and singer from Evanston named Kevin Cronin — a folkie with almost no experience fronting a loud rock band. At his audition, Cronin sang Elton John’s “Holiday Inn.” He got the gig in February 1972.
“I’m Going to Be in That Band Whether They Like It or Not”
Richrath turned out to be the band’s spark plug and its resident force of nature — one of rock’s great underrated guitarists, a fan of Elton John with a hard-rock heart and a Les Paul that sounded like a thunderclap. His original songs lifted REO from bar band to regional powerhouse. But the partnership between the folkie singer and the hard-rock guitarist was combustible from the start.
The album “R.E.O./T.W.O.” came out in 1972 with Cronin on vocals. Then, during the recording of the follow-up, “Ridin’ the Storm Out,” Cronin and Richrath fell out over musical direction — the folkie versus the rocker, the eternal REO fault line. Cronin was out. The band drafted Champaign veteran Mike Murphy, flew to Los Angeles’ Record Plant, and had Murphy re-record all of Cronin’s vocals. “Ridin’ the Storm Out” became REO’s first album to chart, in February 1974, with a title track that remains a concert staple to this day — sung, in a twist the band must have savored, by the replacement vocalist.
Cronin, meanwhile, went solo — opening for the Eagles, Linda Ronstadt, and even Frank Zappa. It was a humbling education. And in 1976, Cronin approached Richrath, the two reconciled, and the classic yin-yang lineup locked in: reformed folkie Cronin writing the melodies, unrepentant rocker Richrath supplying the muscle.
“What Are You, Barry Manilow?”
The reunion didn’t produce instant magic. The 1976 album “R.E.O.” was criticized as overproduced and flopped. But the band made a crucial decision: Cronin and Richrath would write and co-produce everything themselves. They toured relentlessly — with the Eagles, Aerosmith, Bad Company — and built a live following the old-fashioned way, one Midwestern arena at a time. A double live album, “You Get What You Play For” (1977), finally gave them their biggest chart success to date.
Then came the moment that defines the band’s entire story. During rehearsals, Cronin sat down at the piano and started playing a tender ballad he’d written — a song about holding onto love through hard times, drawn from his own life. His bandmates stared at him like he’d lost his mind. “What is that? What are you, Barry Manilow?” Cronin later recalled their reaction. The song was “Keep On Loving You.”
Richrath did what Richrath always did: he plugged in his Les Paul and hit huge, ringing chords, “trashing it out” until Kevin’s folk song became something bigger. As Cronin later described their formula: “Kevin writes a little folk song, Gary trashes it out, and then you got something.” That’s where it all coalesced — the exact alchemy of REO Speedwagon. “Keep On Loving You” became REO’s first No. 1 single and the centerpiece of “Hi Infidelity” (1980) — an album that spent fifteen weeks at No. 1 and sold more than ten million copies, eventually certified diamond. The ballad nobody wanted became the song everybody loved.
The follow-ups kept coming: “Take It On the Run,” “Can’t Fight This Feeling” (their second No. 1, from 1984’s “Wheels Are Turnin’”). Fun footnote: the 1978 album “You Can Tune a Piano, But You Can’t Tuna Fish” — home of “Roll With the Changes,” which Cronin had scribbled on a paper bag back in 1972 — was delivered six months late and $200,000 over budget, fueling what one chronicler delicately called the band’s “offstage powder’n’chicks excesses.”
Fifteen Weeks at the Top
“Hi Infidelity” didn’t just succeed — it detonated. Released in November 1980, it spent fifteen weeks at No. 1 on the Billboard album chart and eventually sold more than ten million copies, earning a diamond certification. “Keep On Loving You” and “Take It On the Run” were inescapable; the album’s polished heartland rock became the default sound of American radio. REO — the bar band from Champaign that couldn’t chart a debut — were suddenly one of the biggest bands on earth.
The triumph validated the strangest partnership in rock: Cronin’s bleeding-heart melodies and Richrath’s barbed-wire guitar. It was a formula nobody else had. When Cronin brought in a delicate piano ballad, Richrath roughed it up; when Richrath brought in a riff, Cronin found the ache inside it. “Take It On the Run,” “Don’t Let Him Go,” “In Your Letter” — the hits kept coming because the friction kept sparking.
The follow-ups held the line: 1982’s “Good Trouble,” then 1984’s “Wheels Are Turnin’,” which delivered their second No. 1 single, “Can’t Fight This Feeling” — another Cronin piano ballad that Richrath’s guitar lifted into the stratosphere. By the mid-eighties, REO were elder statesmen of arena rock, touring with Styx as co-headliners on the “Arch Allies” trek in 2001, two Midwestern institutions sharing one stage and splitting the night fifty-fifty. The folkie and the rocker had built something that lasted decades longer than anyone in that dorm basement could have imagined.
Ten Million Copies and a Slow Unraveling
Success on that scale has a way of magnifying every crack. By the late eighties, the old tensions — the folkie versus the rocker, the road weariness, the shifting musical climate — resurfaced. After 1987’s “Life as We Know It” went gold but signaled fading momentum, both Richrath and Gratzer were gone by decade’s end. REO soldiered on with replacements, but the classic era was over. Richrath, the force of nature who’d muscled his way into the band, died in 2015.
And yet the band kept touring — for decades, one of the most reliable live acts in America, selling out sheds and casinos on the eternal strength of those Hi Infidelity anthems.
The Bitter End — and the Homecoming
Which makes the ending all the more poignant. In late 2024, a disagreement between Kevin Cronin and bassist Bruce Hall — over whether Hall, recovering from surgery, was ready to tour — fractured the band beyond repair. Unable to agree, they made an extraordinary decision: end REO Speedwagon entirely. After 57 years, sixteen studio albums, and forty million records sold, the band retired on January 1, 2025.
Cronin toured through 2025 with the final lineup billed as the Kevin Cronin Band, playing the REO catalog. Meanwhile, Hall, Doughty, and Gratzer staged a farewell concert in their hometown of Champaign on June 14, 2025 — without Cronin. It looked like a permanent, bitter split.
Then, that fall, something shifted. Cronin reunited with Hall, Doughty, and Gratzer as grand marshals of the University of Illinois homecoming parade, and the four classic-era members took the field with the Fighting Illini marching band at halftime — during the Illinois vs. USC game — to play “Ridin’ the Storm Out,” “Roll With the Changes,” and “157 Riverside Avenue.” The song Cronin had been fired over fifty years earlier, performed with the men who fired him, in front of a home crowd, with a college marching band behind them. You couldn’t script a better ending if you tried.
REO Speedwagon was always a band built on friction — folk versus rock, singer versus guitarist, ambition versus loyalty. It produced firings and feuds, a singer who vanished into the dark, and a ballad mocked in rehearsal that became immortal. Forty million records, thirteen Top 40 hits, two No. 1 singles, and a fifteen-week reign at the top of the charts — all from a band named after a 1915 flatbed truck, discovered by a manager nobody had heard of, fronted by a folkie nobody thought could sing rock. And in the end, it produced something rarer than any of that: a homecoming. The truck kept rolling, one way or another, all the way back to Champaign.
Leave a Reply